Oct. 29th, 2013

marjaerwin: (Default)
Another feminist, who I respect, has called me out on the ways we drive away older feminists, and generally we drive away good people. I think that, as trans womyn, so many of us are so used to being hurt by bad allies, that we drive away all allies, which hurts them and hurts us even more.

We expect that other feminists understand trans feminism and our constantly-shifting language, even if we don’t all understand intersex feminism, or womanism, or sex workers’ feminism, or the other outgroup feminisms we should be working besides and/or among. We are all someone’s bad allies. and should try to be better allies.

We sometimes take the worst anti-trans works of the second and third waves and take them as representatives of the rest. We sometimes take the pro-trans works and take them apart because their theory isn’t our theory. We too often ignore all the other works and the ideas from these older feminist traditions.

Look at how cisheterosexist empires have tried to destroy our communities and our histories. Look at how many of us thought we were all alone. Look at the generations trans womyn have spent rebuilding our community and redefining our understanding of ourselves. Well among these outgroup feminisms we have one of our wider communities, and in their history we have one of our histories, and if we destroy this we are doing the cisheterosexist empires’ work for them.

I don’t want to do that any more. Do any of us?

[cross-posted from tumblr]
marjaerwin: (Default)
I reblogged that essay trashing Lou Reed. But fuck. I did wrong. I helped trash someone. I don’t know why. Because one of the things he was being celebrated for was being an ally to our older sisters, but he was an imperfect ally. So yes, we should try to encourage people to do better, but we shouldn’t be so ready to trash people for doing some good.

I’m not going to reread and reevaluate that essay just yet.

I’m more concerned about what this says about me. I mean, I’ve heard all about trashing, I’ve written against trashing, and here, I’ve enabled it. I’ve failed to apply my own moral common sense.

Profile

marjaerwin: (Default)
marjaerwin

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
45678910
11121314151617
1819202122 2324
25262728293031

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 20th, 2025 01:43 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios